Friday, January 15, 2010
My Emotional Journey
Sunday, January 3, 2010
How I feel about blogging
Applying Of Mice and Men to our lives today.
At the end of the book, George kills Lennie. Mrs. Foster asked our class the question, was George killing Lennie a “Mercy Killing.” My answer to this question from my analyzing the data was yes. I will explain my answer in a moment. First, I would like to address the phrase “Mercy Killing.”
Here are some definitions provided by various sites:
1. The Free Online Dictionary- Noun1.mercy killing - the act of killing someone painlessly (especially someone suffering from an incurable illness)
2. www.ecancerawareness.com/cancer_glossary/m.php - An easy or painless death, or the intentional ending of the life of a person suffering from an incurable or painful disease at his or her request. Also called euthanasia.
It is putting a living thing, Lennie in the book, to death, usually because of pain or suffering. Now for the reason that I chose yes. I chose yes, for many different reasons. Here are the main ones. First, he had a mental illness unknown to us as readers and wherever he went, he got into trouble. If George could get Lennie out of the mess, he was in at the moment it would only keep happening again. Also, the men would’ve caught Lennie, George killing Lennie painlessly was far better than what Curly as going to do to him. I think I remember something about him being tortured and then lynched. Finally, at the end of the book at the pond, Lennie began to hallucinate and he seemed to have finally gone crazy. In that day and time people like Lennie when not treated very well, George put an end to his suffering and eased his pains. That is why I answered yes to the question.
Contrasting the Movie to the Book
To begin with, I imagined Lennie Small as a large man. In the movie, he was larger, but not much larger than the other men were, although he was stronger. In addition, I imagined George to be a little bit smaller, but that is just what I made up in my imagination. Now from what my third period class saw, we did not see the whole movie, the book and the movie were mostly the same. The settings, once again from my point of view, were a little different at parts, like the beginning where the bus driver drops them off and on the way to the ranch. Then some of the parts happened at different locations, like when the men were first talking about shooting Candy’s dog. The plot was just about right on for the book though. Our class ended after the part with Lennie going into Crooks shack, I think, it might have been a little bit after that part. I do remember when the tart was asking Lennie and George about Curley’s hand, which had a wrong setting going by the book, but I can not remember if that happened before or after the shack scene. The shack scene was very well portrayed though. The man who played Crooks did great that was on of my favorite parts during the movie. All in all, the movie and the book were both close together in plot, but a little farther away in setting structure. I greatly enjoyed both the book and the movie.